Shipping policy
Last updated October 26, 2026
We don't ship. Every order is picked up in person at agnello's cafe in Manahawkin.
Where to pick up
agnello's cafe, inside the Manahawkin Flea Market
657 E Bay Ave Unit 2, Manahawkin, NJ 08050
Directions on Google Maps
When your order is ready
You choose a pickup date when you add items to your cart. Your order is ready from 10 AM on that date, and the cafe is open until 4 PM.
- We need two full prep days, not counting the day you order, so the earliest pickup date is the day after tomorrow.
- Some items are only baked on certain days. For example, the long-ferment miche is a Saturday pickup only. The product page shows the dates each item is available.
- Regular pickups are paused around Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter and New Year's Day. Holiday menus have their own order pages and pickup dates.
Picking up
Give the name on your order at the counter. If someone else is collecting for you, they can give your name or order number.
Changes and missed pickups
To move your pickup date, contact us before prep starts, which is two full days before pickup. Orders are held until closing time on the pickup day. See our refund policy for what happens if an order isn't collected.
Contact
Email support@agnellosmkt.com or call (609) 549-5775.